As a serious tea drinker living in Canada, I learned pretty quickly that the quality of your water can make or break a good cup of tea. While Canada has some of the safest tap water in the world, the minerals and chemicals added to it can dramatically change the taste of your favorite brew.
To save you the trouble (and the heartbreak of a ruined tea session), I've tasted and tested some of the most popular bottled water brands in Canada. Here’s a breakdown of what I found, from the best to the absolute worst for your next cup of tea.
The Good: Waters That Elevate Your Tea
💧 Whistler | The BC Secret Weapon
* Taste Profile: Sweet and slightly bitter, with a soft, smooth finish and a hint of a wild, earthy taste.
* Brewing Performance: This water is a true champion for tea. It really lifts the tea’s aroma, making it feel vibrant and fresh without overpowering the subtle notes. It's especially great for Oolong teas, like Da Hong Pao, that rely on a clean flavor profile. It also makes old teas taste smooth and refined.
💧 Aqufina | The New Tea Enthusiast's Go-To
* Taste Profile: Slightly alkaline, with a crisp and clean finish.
* Brewing Performance: This water is excellent for new teas and green teas. It helps bring out the fresh, grassy notes without any added bitterness. It's a fantastic, reliable choice when you want a consistently good cup.
The Bad: Waters That Don't Get Along With Tea
💧 Evian | The Wild Card
* Taste Profile: Hard and slightly acidic, with a very prominent, almost "wild" mineral taste.
* Brewing Performance: This water is a definite no for tea. When heated, its unique mineral profile seems to fall flat, and the tea's flavor becomes dull.
* The Verdict: Best for drinking straight—its crisp, refreshing taste makes it a great pairing for food.
💧 Fiji | The Drinking Water King, the Tea Killer
* Taste Profile: Sweet and smooth, almost creamy. It's incredibly pleasant to drink on its own.
* Brewing Performance: This water is a tea killer. It completely mutes the tea's aroma (especially for rock teas like Wuyi Oolong) and can leave an unpleasant aftertaste. Plus, it causes a lot of scale in your kettle, which is a pain to clean.
* The Verdict: Stick to drinking this one cold, straight out of the bottle. It's a great summer refresher, just not for your teapot.
The Ugly: Waters That Just Miss the Mark
💧 Pure Life | The Tap Water Plus
* Taste Profile: A slightly artificial, plastic-like taste with an unclean aftertaste.
* Brewing Performance: The plasticky flavor completely overpowers your tea's aroma. You can maybe use it for brewing a large pot of a strong, robust tea, but even then, a better-quality purified water would be a superior choice.
💧 Ice River Green Bottle | Absolutely Avoid!
* Taste Profile: I honestly couldn't get past what it did when I heated it.
* Brewing Performance: When boiled, the water turns cloudy and a milky white color. I had to throw out the tea every time I used it. It felt like I was wasting my good tea leaves.
* The Verdict: Please avoid this water for tea at all costs!
To sum it all up, here’s my quick guide for what to buy next time you're at the store.
-
For aged teas & bold, high-aroma brews → Reach for Whistler (it’s your tea’s best friend).
-
For fresh new teas & green teas → Aquafina keeps things crisp and clean.
-
For a quick, no-fuss sip → Grab a Fiji or Evian — smooth, easy, done.
-
When the shelves are bare and all that’s left is Pure Life or Ice River → Don’t stress, just roll with it.
Happy brewing, Canada!